This listing sold on Sun, Jun 1 at 3:30 AM.
⚾️ 1887 N172 Old Judge #84-5 Bill Collins - Catcher Pose Waist High - PSA New
Sold
⚾️ 1887 N172 Old Judge #84-5 Bill Collins - Catcher Pose Waist High - PSA New
US $448.85US $448.85
Sun, Jun 01, 03:30 AMSun, Jun 01, 03:30 AM
Authenticity Guarantee

⚾️ 1887 N172 Old Judge #84-5 Bill Collins - Catcher Pose Waist High - PSA New

US $448.85
or Best Offer
No Interest if paid in full in 6 mo on $149+ with PayPal Credit*
Condition:
Graded - PSA 1 Check PSA data
0 lots available (1 items per lot)1 sold
    Shipping:
    US $7.99 Shipping to authenticator, then to you.
    Located in: Kansas City, MO, United States
    Delivery:
    Estimated between Fri, Jul 18 and Fri, Jul 25 to 94104
    Estimated delivery dates - opens in a new window or tab include seller's handling time, origin ZIP Code, destination ZIP Code and time of acceptance and will depend on shipping service selected and receipt of cleared paymentcleared payment - opens in a new window or tab. Delivery times may vary, especially during peak periods.
    Includes shipping to and from the authenticator
    Returns:
    30 days returns. Seller pays for return shipping.
    Payments:
           .
    *No Interest if paid in full in 6 months on $149+. See terms and apply now- for PayPal Credit, opens in a new window or tab
    Earn up to 5x points when you use your eBay Mastercard®. Learn moreabout earning points with eBay Mastercard

    Shop with confidence

    Authenticity Guarantee
    This item is shipped to an authenticator for verification before delivery. Final sale may apply.
    Top Rated Plus
    Top rated seller, fast shipping, and free returns. Learn more- Top Rated Plus - opens in a new window or tab
    How it works
    Make a purchase
    Shop our ever-expanding range of eligible items.
    Seller ships to eBay
    Your item is sent to an eBay Authentication Center.
    Experts authenticate
    If your item does not pass inspection, we will provide a full refund.
    eBay ships to you
    We repackage your item with its authentication card.
    Seller assumes all responsibility for this listing.
    eBay item number:167447024488
    Last updated on May 18, 2025 21:37:54 PDTView all revisionsView all revisions

    Item specifics

    Condition
    Graded - PSA 1: Professionally graded
    Card Size
    Tobacco
    Sport
    Baseball
    League
    Major League (MLB)
    Type
    Sports Trading Card
    Set
    1887 N172 Old Judge
    Manufacturer
    Old Judge Tobacco
    Material
    Card Stock
    Player/Athlete
    Bill Collins
    Team
    New York Metropolitans
    Card Number
    84-5
    Country/Region of Manufacture
    United States
    Season
    1887
    Professional Grader
    Professional Sports Authenticator (PSA)
    Grade
    1
    Certification Number
    101792043
    Category

    Item description from the seller

    About this seller

    Premier Card Collectors

    100% positive feedback3.1K items sold

    Joined Jan 2014
    Usually responds within 24 hours
    We have been collecting since 1977. As a Top Rated Plus seller we are committed to delivering the highest level of customer service to our buyers. We will likely never be the lowest priced on eBay but ...
    See more

    Detailed seller ratings

    Average for the last 12 months
    Accurate description
    5.0
    Reasonable shipping cost
    4.9
    Shipping speed
    5.0
    Communication
    5.0

    Seller feedback (1,431)

    All ratings
    Positive
    Neutral
    Negative
    • p***p (32)- Feedback left by buyer.
      Past month
      Verified purchase
      Just recently purchased so I might add an update once I receive. The sellers are super good people and you can tell dedicated to this profession. Their communication is spot on, pricing is competitive and just looking at the picture the item is high quality and looks to be in great condition. I'm looking forward to receiving the Bender Old Mill and I know I'll purchase from Premier Card Collectors again.
      Reply from: premiercardcollectors- Feedback replied by seller premiercardcollectors.- Feedback replied by seller premiercardcollectors.
      Thank you so much for the kind words. Can't wait for you to receive the card. We hope that you love it as much as we do. So excited to have you as a customer and hope to serve you again soon. We also buy every day so if you are selling please let us know and check our listings daily for updates. Constantly looking to fill holes in our collection as well. For the Love of the Hobby. Best. Geoff
    • j***o (701)- Feedback left by buyer.
      Past 6 months
      Verified purchase
      We feel value when purchases are made from PREMIER CARD COLLECTORS. The 1909-1911 T-206 Sweet Caporal tobacco card of NEAL BALL, New York, A.L., arrived well packed, secured with rigid plastic sheets, a bubble-wrap shipping envelope, and ON-TIME. NEAL BALL is favorite card because of the unique history of being the first player to perform an unassisted triple play. The graded card is as described, AND, reflects on this 5-STAR Dealer's great inventory. Thank you for a nice price.
      Reply from: premiercardcollectors- Feedback replied by seller premiercardcollectors.- Feedback replied by seller premiercardcollectors.
      Thank you so much for the kind review. I am so glad you love the card as much as we did. We look forward to serving you again in the future. Best - Geoff PCC
    • e***a (155)- Feedback left by buyer.
      Past month
      Verified purchase
      Card arrived well packaged and just as described and in images. Seller communicated once item was shipped. I would recommend the seller and would definitely buy again. Thank you!