I didn't feel like spending $300 on a pan from the autoparts stores so I went with this one. The quality seems good enough, with it being thick and strong, though I'm not an engineer. Time will tell. My only complaint though minor is the metal dowels would not fit in the holes to align it. So I popped them out. Make sure you do a dry fit first, otherwise you'll have a big mess cleaning up the gasket sealant when you have to do it all over again. I've put 500 miles on so far and no leaks. It was a somewhat fun DIY project, never having done that before. Removing the exhaust was a PITA though.