Featured categories
Featured items
All items

Magic the Gathering (MTG) Secret Lair x Fallout: S.P.E.C.I.A.L (Foil)
$125.00

Magic the Gathering (MTG) Secret Lair x Fallout: S.P.E.C.I.A.L (Non-Foil)
$100.00

Magic the Gathering (MTG) Secret Lair x Fallout: Points of Interest (Foil)
$100.00

Magic the Gathering MTG Secret Lair x Dungeons & Dragons Astarion's Thirst Foil
$99.99

Magic the Gathering (MTG) Secret Lair: Through the Wormhole Sealed! (Non-Foil)
$175.00

Magic the Gathering (MTG) - Secret Lair x Stranger Things (Non-Foil)
$100.00

Magic the Gathering (MTG) Secret Lair - Just Add Milk: Second Helpings (Foil)
$89.99

Magic the Gathering (MTG) Secret Lair x Fallout: Vault Boy (Rainbow Foil)
$100.00

Magic the Gathering (MTG) Secret Lair: Drop Series - LOOK AT THE KITTIES (Foil)
$275.00

Magic the Gathering (MTG) Secret Lair - Phyrexian Praetors (Compleat Foil)
$100.00

Serra's Sanctum [Urza's Saga] MTG Moderately Played
$250.00

Magic the Gathering (MTG) Secret Lair: Drop Series - The Art of Frank Frazetta
$250.00

Enduring Curiosity (Japan Showcase Fracture Foil) [Duskmourn] MTG NM Foil
$350.00

Magic the Gathering (MTG) Secret Lair - The '90s Binder Experience (Foil)
$175.00

Magic the Gathering (MTG) Secret Lair x Monty Python: Vol 1 (Foil)
$125.00

Magic the Gathering (MTG) Secret Lair x Monty Python: Vol 1 (Non-Foil)
$109.99

Magic the Gathering (MTG) Secret Lair - Meditations on Nature (Foil)
$125.00

Weiss Schwarz 🔥 BOFURI: I Don't Want to Get Hurt Booster Box English 🔥
$250.00

Magic the Gathering (MTG) Secret Lair - The '90s Binder Experience (Non-Foil)
$125.00

Secret Lair Drop Series: Ponies - The Galloping 2 (Extra Life 2023) (Foil)
$175.00

Secret Lair Drop Series: Ponies - The Galloping 2 (Extra Life 2023) (Non Foil)
$125.00

Magic the Gathering (MTG) Secret Lair x Hatsune Miku: Digital Sensation (Foil)
$125.00

Magic the Gathering (MTG) Secret Lair - Special Guest: kozyndan (The Lands)
$125.00

Magic the Gathering (MTG) Secret Lair Drop: Tales of the Time Stoppers (Foil)
$100.00

Control Magic Summer Magic / Edgar # 52 Magic the Gathering LP!
$1,189.99

Underground Sea Limited Edition Alpha # 285 Magic the Gathering HP!
$11,989.99

Enduring Vitality (Japan Showcase Fracture Foil) [Duskmourn] MTG NM Foil
$325.00

Jace, the Mind Sculptor (Borderless) Secret Lair Drop Promos # 8001 MTG!
$699.00

Enduring Innocence (Japan Showcase Fracture Foil) [Duskmourn] MTG NM Foil
$150.00

Mox Opal (Toppers) [Double Masters] MTG Near Mint
$250.00

Magic the Gathering (MTG) Secret Lair x Marvel's Iron Man (Rainbow Foil)
$125.00

Magic the Gathering (MTG) Secret Lair - The Beauty of the Beasts (Rainbow Foil)
$150.00

Mox Opal [Modern Masters 2015] MTG Near Mint Foil
$250.00

Flesh and Blood Ruu'di Gem Keeper LSS001-P FaB Rudy Promo - Complete Box!
$1,199.00

Jace, the Mind Sculptor (Borderless) Secret Lair Promos # 8001 FOIL Pro Tour NM!
$4,989.00

Mox Pearl Unlimited Edition # 264 Magic the Gathering LP!
$4,489.99

Flooded Strand Onslaught # 316 FOIL Magic the Gathering NM!
$1,479.99

2020-21 Panini Origins Basketball Hobby Box FOTL 🔥IN HAND🔥
$1,289.99

Mox Sapphire Unlimited Edition # 266 Magic the Gathering HP!
$3,889.99

Vesuvan Doppelganger Limited Edition Beta # 88 Magic the Gathering MP!
$2,089.99

Ancestral Recall Limited Edition Alpha # 47 Magic the Gathering MP!
$18,989.99

Zodiac Dragon Portal Three Kingdoms # 131 MTG Lightly Played!
$1,069.99

2022 National Treasures NFL Box Factory Sealed In-Hand FIRST OFF THE LINE, FOTL!
$6,989.00

Library of Alexandria Arabian Nights # 76 Magic the Gathering MP!
$1,699.99

Time Walk Unlimited Edition# 84 Magic the Gathering NM!
$8,489.99

Mox Emerald Unlimited Edition # 262 Magic the Gathering LP!
$5,389.99

Magic the Gathering (MTG) Secret Lair - The Beauty of the Beasts (Non Foil)
$99.99

Magic the Gathering (MTG) Secret Lair Drop Series - Just Add Milk (Foil Edition)
$99.99
About us
Control your magic.
We specialize in MTG and other TCGs.
Combined shipping at checkout. eBay site for Control Magic LLC (www.control-magic.com).
We specialize in MTG and other TCGs.
Combined shipping at checkout. eBay site for Control Magic LLC (www.control-magic.com).
Seller feedback (2,823)
- s***n (104)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseItem as described, fast shipping, packaged well and fair price. A+++ Seller!
- o***e (6)- Feedback left by buyer.More than a year agoVerified purchaseThe card I received in the mail was not the one pictured and I learned that eBay will sometimes pull photos for items automatically. I was disappointed and contacted the seller, but they were more than reasonable in negotiating a price we could both agree on. Excellent customer service. Excellent shipping time and packaging. This will be my first stop when I'm looking for MTG items in the future
- s***o (468)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseThe card was well packed, secure, and protected. The card is in perfect condition as described. Fast shipping. Awesome and recommended seller.
- l***o (175)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseGreat seller. Fast delivery, card handling and condition was as described. It looks awesome. Very communicative and honest. Thanks!
- w***2 (942)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseGreat packaging well protected great value, shipping was great and was exactly as described
- 1***w (6)- Feedback left by buyer.Past monthVerified purchaseThought I was getting foil. My own fault for not reading the listing.. seller sent items fast. Packaged well. Value was over priced.Reply from: controlmagic- Feedback replied by seller controlmagic.- Feedback replied by seller controlmagic.New ebay user looking for a 'too good to be true' price. Listing clearly indicated non-foil, and we have free no hassle returns. Pricing is competitive with other platforms and ebay.