Featured categories
Newly Listed
See all
1889 Better Date Indian Head Cent receive coin pictured see description #4719
$2.95
1888 Better Date Indian Head Cent receive coin pictured see description #4718
$4.95
1888 Better Date Indian Head Cent receive coin pictured see description #4717
$3.95
1888 Better Date Indian Head Cent receive coin pictured see description #4716
$3.95
1887 Better Date Indian Head Cent receive coin pictured see description #4715
$3.95
1887 Better Date Indian Head Cent receive coin pictured see description #4714
$2.95
Featured items
1869 Semi-Key Indian Head Cent Choice AU coin pictured see description 😍 #4558
$599.95
1970-S SMALL DATE Cent PCGS PR69RD 1 of 31 with none graded higher #3950
$599.95
1914-S High-Grade Semi-Key Date Lincoln Wheat 1c PCGS EF45 see description #3935
$124.95
1828 Scarce Small/Wide Date N-10/R-2 Coronet Head Lg Cent see description #2984
$79.95
1896-O Better Date Morgan $ PCGS AU-58 Perfect for Everyman Registry Set #3817
$599.95
All items
1869 Semi-Key Indian Head Cent Choice AU coin pictured see description 😍 #4558
$599.95
1886 Type 2 Better Date Indian Head Cent EF receive coin pictured #4571
$194.95
1970-S SMALL DATE Cent PCGS PR69RD 1 of 31 with none graded higher #3950
$599.95
1913 Type 1 Buffalo Nickel GEM BU receive coin pictured see description #4620
$149.95
1909 VDB Lincoln Wheat Cent PCGS/MS64RD coin pictured see description #4638
$124.95
2023 EXTRA-V Rare Variety Lincoln Shield Reverse Cent ANACS MS67RD #4621
$449.95
1866 Low Mintage Indian Head Cent receive coin pictured see description #4555
$99.95
1909-VDB Lincoln Wheat Cent PCGS MS65RD 41794412 receive coin pictured see video
$199.95
1859 Copper-Nickel Indian Head Cent receive coin pictured see description #4584
$19.95
1883 Better Date Indian Head Cent EF receive coin pictured see description #4568
$23.95
1863 Copper-Nickel Indian Head Cent receive coin pictured see description #4588
$12.95
1880 STUNNING RB-BU Indian Head Cent receive coin pictured see description #4565
$199.95
1861 Copper-Nickel Indian Head Cent receive coin pictured see description #4586
$19.95
1867/67 Tough Date Indian Head Cent receive coin pictured see description #3938
$199.95
CDN Monthly Greysheet Publication May 2025 Be The First To Get One!!!
$39.95
1864-1909 38pc partial set w/ better dates 66-68-69-70-71-72 Indian Head Cents
$399.95
1889 Better Date Indian Head Cent receive coin pictured see description #4719
$2.95
1870 Shallow-N Indian Head Cent EF receive coin pictured see description #4559
$474.95
1930-S Lincoln Wheat 1c Full RED BU+ receive coin pictured see description #4499
$59.95
1865 Plain 5 Indian Head Cent AU receive coin pictured see description #4554
$94.95
1885 Better Date Indian Head Cent AU receive coin pictured see description #4569
$94.95
1887 Better Date Indian Head Cent receive coin pictured see description #4713
$2.95
1887 Better Date Indian Head Cent receive coin pictured see description #4714
$2.95
1886 Type 1 Better Date Indian Head Cent EF+ receive coin pictured #4570
$179.95
1883 No Cents Type Liberty V Nickel receive coin pictured see description #4598
$12.95
1888 Better Date Indian Head Cent receive coin pictured see description #4716
$3.95
1888 Better Date Indian Head Cent receive coin pictured see description #4717
$3.95
1887 Better Date Indian Head Cent receive coin pictured see description #4715
$3.95
1888 Better Date Indian Head Cent receive coin pictured see description #4718
$4.95
1864-L RPD FS-2306 S-10 Indian Head Cent PCGS EF Details see description #3769
$299.95
1859 Copper-Nickel Indian Head 1c EF+ receive coin pictured see description#4548
$169.95
1858 Flying Eagle Cent Large Letters receive coin pictured see description #4546
$76.95
1884 Better Date Indian Head Cent receive coin pictured see description #4712
$19.95
1892 Indian Head Cent Unc Details receive coin pictured see description #4577
$49.95
1918-S Better Date Lincoln Wheat AU+ receive coin pictured see description #4633
$44.95
1910 Early Year Lincoln Wheat Cent receive coin pictured see description #4612
$14.95
1909 VDB Lincoln Wheat Cent receive coin pictured see description #4639
$8.95
1914 Lincoln Wheat Cent AU Details receive coin pictured see description #4631
$19.95
1864 L Ribbon/Pointed Bust Indian Head coin pictured see description #3087
$19.95
1913 Type 2 Buffalo Nickel VF+ receive coin pictured see description #4605
$19.95
1979-S Type 1 "Filled" S Washington Quarter Amazing Deep Cameo Gem Proof #5204
$3.95
1867 Low Mintage Indian Head Cent VF receive coin pictured see description #4556
$129.95
1882 Counterstamped Indian Head Cent receive coin pictured see description #4705
$7.95
1861 Low Mintage CN Indian Head 1c VF receive coin pictured see description#4550
$69.95
1880 Better Date Indian Head Cent receive coin pictured see description #4486
$49.95
1883 Better Date Indian Head Cent receive coin pictured see description #4706
$8.95
1840 Sm Date Braided Hair Lg Cent Fine receive coin pictured see description3411
$49.95
1909 Lincoln Wheat Cent BN Choice Unc receive coin pictured see description 4611
$39.95
About us
Welcome to More Than Common Cents! Here to help you build your collection, big or small. Bringing 40+ years of numismatic expertise to the table, our goal is your satisfaction. We are very proud of our excellent Positive Feedback score that we have maintained since 2004. Stay tuned as we are constantly growing our offerings.
Store policies
Shipping
Returns
Seller feedback (2,622)
- r***0 (1760)- Feedback left by buyer.Past monthVerified purchaseFantastic buying experience. Items were shipped super quick and items were well packaged and items were as described in the listing. Seller is super competitive in price and has great communication with buyers. I Highly recommend this seller and would buy from them in the future. Thank you for the great buying experience.
- 4***5 (265)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseThe coin arrived today in great shape. It was packaged in secure cardboard and in a bubble wrap EBAY envelope. The coin took a detour to Denver and took a little extra time to arrive, but that is on the Post Office, not the seller. The seller keep in contact with me throughout the coins journey. The coin is beautiful, as described in the ad. The price was appropriate . Thank you!!
- c***c (550)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseGreat seller offering reasonable prices, fast shipping, great communication. Well packaged for shipmentand item received was item pictured. Very pleased with the transaction. This seller is A++++
- p***n (356)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseVery nice coin. Coin received were the same as the one advertised. Packaging was secure and no issues with shipping. I'm happy with my purchase. I've now bought a few coins from this seller and will definitely buy again. The coins are well cared for, are blemish free, and come sealed in their own individual packets. The low cost of the coins is suprising in relation to their quality. I think they will grade very high.
- 9***n (31)- Feedback left by buyer.Past yearVerified purchaseWONDERFUL seller! One of the best I've worked with on eBay so far. He posted videos of the item when I requested them, responded to my communications quickly, and even took my offer! Great price, extremely fast shipping, well packaged, attention to detail — truly one of the best sellers I've encountered.
- 9***e (834)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseSilver quarter arrived on time and exactly as described! A+++++ seller, excellent communication, perfectly packaged! I recommend this seller to anyone. Thank You