Skip to main content

Best selling products: Best Retired Ty Beanie Buddies

BestsellingTop Rated
Ty Beanie Buddy USA Flag Bear Named Spangle 3rd Generation MINT 1999
Rank 1
Ty Beanie Buddy USA Flag Bear Named Spangle 3rd Generation MINT 1999
(3)
$7.64 New
$2.32 Used
Ty 2001 Beanie Buddy Spunky Brown/buff Cocker Spaniel Dog 13"plush 3 Boy Girl Ct
Rank 2
Ty 2001 Beanie Buddy Spunky Brown/buff Cocker Spaniel Dog 13"plush 3 Boy Girl Ct
(1)
$9.95 New
$4.99 Used
Ty Princess Beanie Buddy - Purple (9329)
Rank 3
Ty Princess Beanie Buddy - Purple (9329)
(15)
$19.50 New
$12.00 Used
Ty Beanie Buddy Erin Irish Shamrock Bear Large 15" Plush Stuffed Animal 1998
Rank 4
Ty Beanie Buddy Erin Irish Shamrock Bear Large 15" Plush Stuffed Animal 1998
(9)
$13.89 New
$9.99 Used
Ty Beanie Buddy 14" Teddy Old Face Teal Bear Plush Stuffed Animal Tagged 2000
Rank 5
Ty Beanie Buddy 14" Teddy Old Face Teal Bear Plush Stuffed Animal Tagged 2000
(3)
$6.75 New
$5.20 Used
2001 Ty Floppity Purple Beanie Buddy 13" Plush Bunny Easter Rabbit 3
Rank 6
2001 Ty Floppity Purple Beanie Buddy 13" Plush Bunny Easter Rabbit 3
$16.99 New
$12.99 Used
Ty Original Beanie Buddy Collection 2000 Mystic The Unicorn With Tags 12 Inch
Rank 7
Ty Original Beanie Buddy Collection 2000 Mystic The Unicorn With Tags 12 Inch
(5)
$16.89 New
No used products available
Ty rare Retired Cat Ty Beanie Buddy - CHIP the Cat (13 Inch) Plush Stuffed Toy
Rank 8
Ty rare Retired Cat Ty Beanie Buddy - CHIP the Cat (13 Inch) Plush Stuffed Toy
(8)
$14.95 New
No used products available
Ty Beanie Buddy Dotty The Dalmatian Dog 3rd Generation MINT 1999
Rank 9
Ty Beanie Buddy Dotty The Dalmatian Dog 3rd Generation MINT 1999
$23.89 New
$15.00 Used
Ty 2001 Swoop The Pterodactyl Dinosaur Beanie Buddy - With Tags
Rank 10
Ty 2001 Swoop The Pterodactyl Dinosaur Beanie Buddy - With Tags
(1)
$15.89 New
$10.00 Used
Jake 12in Mallard Duck Retired 1998 Ty Beanie Buddy Buddie 3up Boys Girls 9304
Rank 11
Jake 12in Mallard Duck Retired 1998 Ty Beanie Buddy Buddie 3up Boys Girls 9304
(3)
$8.96 New
No used products available
Ty 2003 Beanie Buddies 14" Bear Named Birthday Buddy Hat Pastel Colors
Rank 12
Ty 2003 Beanie Buddies 14" Bear Named Birthday Buddy Hat Pastel Colors
$18.89 New
$17.99 Used
TY Beanie Buddy Plush Polar Bear Chilly Floppy Bean Bag Lay Stuffed Animal Toy
Rank 13
TY Beanie Buddy Plush Polar Bear Chilly Floppy Bean Bag Lay Stuffed Animal Toy
(3)
$15.89 New
$7.99 Used
Ty Beanie Buddy Parrot Named Jabber 3rd Generation MINT Plush Toy 1999
Rank 14
Ty Beanie Buddy Parrot Named Jabber 3rd Generation MINT Plush Toy 1999
(1)
$11.99 New
No used products available
Ty Beanie Buddy Pooky Plush Stuffed Toy Garfield Teddy Bear Collectible 2004
Rank 15
Ty Beanie Buddy Pooky Plush Stuffed Toy Garfield Teddy Bear Collectible 2004
(2)
$69.89 New
$9.69 Used
Ty Beanie Buddy Cat Named Amber Orange Tabby 3rd Generation MINT Plush Toy
Rank 16
Ty Beanie Buddy Cat Named Amber Orange Tabby 3rd Generation MINT Plush Toy
(5)
$18.95 New
$16.99 Used
Ty 2001 Legs The Frog Beanie Buddy
Rank 17
Ty 2001 Legs The Frog Beanie Buddy
(3)
$23.95 New
No used products available
Vintage Ty Beanie Buddy Humphrey The Camel 1998 Retired MWMTS 008421093076
Rank 18
Vintage Ty Beanie Buddy Humphrey The Camel 1998 Retired MWMTS 008421093076
(4)
$13.49 New
$10.79 Used
Ty Beanie Buddy Bunny Flippity Rabbit 3rd Generation Sky Blue Pink 1999
Rank 19
Ty Beanie Buddy Bunny Flippity Rabbit 3rd Generation Sky Blue Pink 1999
(4)
$17.05 New
$11.66 Used
B9 Ty Speedy The Turtle Beanie Buddy 12" 1999
Rank 20
B9 Ty Speedy The Turtle Beanie Buddy 12" 1999
(3)
$11.40 New
$6.99 Used
2003 Ty Beanie Buddy 13" Plush Dippy Pastel Bunny Rabbit Stuffed
Rank 21
2003 Ty Beanie Buddy 13" Plush Dippy Pastel Bunny Rabbit Stuffed
(4)
$11.09 New
$8.99 Used
Ty Bones 2000 Plush Brown Dog 14 RARE Beanie Buddy MWMT
Rank 22
Ty Bones 2000 Plush Brown Dog 14 RARE Beanie Buddy MWMT
(2)
$17.95 New
No used products available
Ty 9406 Beanie Buddy India The Tiger
Rank 23
Ty 9406 Beanie Buddy India The Tiger
(1)
$22.89 New
$13.50 Used
2003 Ty Beanie Buddies Mr Wedding Plush White Bear Groom EUC Buddy Bud
Rank 24
2003 Ty Beanie Buddies Mr Wedding Plush White Bear Groom EUC Buddy Bud
(1)
$11.89 New
No used products available
Ty Beanie Buddy Cat Named Zip 3rd Generation Black & White MINT 1999
Rank 25
Ty Beanie Buddy Cat Named Zip 3rd Generation Black & White MINT 1999
(7)
$25.19 New
$17.99 Used
2 Ty Beanie Buddies 11" Plush Spring White Easter Bunny Rabbits With Tags 2002
Rank 26
2 Ty Beanie Buddies 11" Plush Spring White Easter Bunny Rabbits With Tags 2002
(1)
$20.89 New
$15.00 Used
Purple Employee Bear Ty Beanie Buddy 14in Stuffed Animal Doll MWMT 9373
Rank 27
Purple Employee Bear Ty Beanie Buddy 14in Stuffed Animal Doll MWMT 9373
(2)
$11.99 New
$6.50 Used
Ty Frisbee Beanie Buddy Weimaraner Puppy Dog 2002
Rank 28
Ty Frisbee Beanie Buddy Weimaraner Puppy Dog 2002
(1)
$49.89 New
$29.99 Used
Osito Retired 1999 Ty Beanie Buddy Mexican Flag 13in Red Teddy Bear 3up 9344
Rank 29
Osito Retired 1999 Ty Beanie Buddy Mexican Flag 13in Red Teddy Bear 3up 9344
(4)
$4.50 New
$1.80 Used
Ty Beanie Buddy Original Sakura Bear Japan Plush Stuff Animal 2000
Rank 30
Ty Beanie Buddy Original Sakura Bear Japan Plush Stuff Animal 2000
$22.89 New
$14.99 Used
Ty Beanie Buddies Plush Starlett Kitty Cat White 11 Inch 2002 TySilk Buddy W/tag
Rank 31
Ty Beanie Buddies Plush Starlett Kitty Cat White 11 Inch 2002 TySilk Buddy W/tag
(1)
$34.99 New
$34.99 Used
Ty Beanie Buddy Silver The Cat Tabby 3rd Generation MINT Plush Toy 1999
Rank 32
Ty Beanie Buddy Silver The Cat Tabby 3rd Generation MINT Plush Toy 1999
(3)
$31.89 New
$14.00 Used
Ty Beanie Buddy 2003 Bonsai The Chimpanzee Monkey With Tags 15"
Rank 33
Ty Beanie Buddy 2003 Bonsai The Chimpanzee Monkey With Tags 15"
(4)
$45.95 New
$38.66 Used
Ty Beanie Buddy McWooly The Green St. Patrick Bear 13 Beanbag Plush 90018
Rank 34
Ty Beanie Buddy McWooly The Green St. Patrick Bear 13 Beanbag Plush 90018
(2)
$29.89 New
$22.31 Used
Ty Beanie Buddy 2001 Collection Trumpet The Elephant
Rank 35
Ty Beanie Buddy 2001 Collection Trumpet The Elephant
(1)
$13.30 New
No used products available
Ty 2001 Dearest The Peach Bear Beanie Buddy With Tags T16
Rank 36
Ty 2001 Dearest The Peach Bear Beanie Buddy With Tags T16
(2)
$5.49 New
No used products available
Ty Beanie Buddies 16" Rainbow Chameleon Plush Bean Bag Lizard 1999 09367
Rank 37
Ty Beanie Buddies 16" Rainbow Chameleon Plush Bean Bag Lizard 1999 09367
(1)
$15.95 New
$6.99 Used
Ty Original Beanie Buddy Neon Seahorse 16 Inch Plush Stuffed Animal Toy 2001
Rank 38
Ty Original Beanie Buddy Neon Seahorse 16 Inch Plush Stuffed Animal Toy 2001
(1)
$17.89 New
No used products available
Almond Retired 2001 Ty Beanie Buddy 12in Plush Bear 3up Boys Girls 9425
Rank 39
Almond Retired 2001 Ty Beanie Buddy 12in Plush Bear 3up Boys Girls 9425
$16.95 New
$9.99 Used
Vintage Ty Beanie Buddy Pinky the Flamingo 1998 Rare Stuffed Animal Plush W/Tag
Rank 40
Vintage Ty Beanie Buddy Pinky the Flamingo 1998 Rare Stuffed Animal Plush W/Tag
(5)
$9.30 New
$7.20 Used
Ty Beanie Buddie Parfum French Poodle Plush With Tags Pink 2003
Rank 41
Ty Beanie Buddie Parfum French Poodle Plush With Tags Pink 2003
(3)
$24.95 New
$5.00 Used
Retired Ty 2002 Holiday Teddy Beanie Buddy Mwmt4g Swing
Rank 42
Retired Ty 2002 Holiday Teddy Beanie Buddy Mwmt4g Swing
(1)
$10.00 New
No used products available
RARE RETIRED Wallace The Bear Ty Beanie Buddy 2000 Beanbag Plush U
Rank 43
RARE RETIRED Wallace The Bear Ty Beanie Buddy 2000 Beanbag Plush U
$11.89 New
$5.99 Used
Ty 2003 Woody The Bear Beanie Buddy - With Tags
Rank 44
Ty 2003 Woody The Bear Beanie Buddy - With Tags
$23.99 New
$3.60 Used
TY Original Beanie Buddy Oats The Brown Horse 12” Plush Stuffed Animal 2001
Rank 45
TY Original Beanie Buddy Oats The Brown Horse 12” Plush Stuffed Animal 2001
(1)
$13.30 New
No used products available
Ty Beanie Buddies Cassie 2001 Collie Dog With Tag
Rank 46
Ty Beanie Buddies Cassie 2001 Collie Dog With Tag
(4)
$19.79 New
No used products available
Ty Tangerine Orange Bear Soft Napped Version 12" Beanie Buddy 2001 Plush 3 MWMT
Rank 47
Ty Tangerine Orange Bear Soft Napped Version 12" Beanie Buddy 2001 Plush 3 MWMT
(1)
$16.89 New
$14.95 Used
Ty White Tiger Cat Blizzard 13" Beanie Buddy Plush 2000 Boys Girls 3 NT
Rank 48
Ty White Tiger Cat Blizzard 13" Beanie Buddy Plush 2000 Boys Girls 3 NT
(1)
$15.00 New
$6.30 Used
Ty Beanie Buddy Bear Teddy Cranberry 2nd Generation MINT 1998
Rank 49
Ty Beanie Buddy Bear Teddy Cranberry 2nd Generation MINT 1998
(6)
$10.00 New
$7.00 Used
TY BEANIE BUDDY Squealer The PIG MWMT in Tag Protector
Rank 50
TY BEANIE BUDDY Squealer The PIG MWMT in Tag Protector
(3)
$6.99 New
No used products available
TY Beanie Buddy CHOCOLATE The Moose Beanie Buddy No Swing Tag
Rank 51
TY Beanie Buddy CHOCOLATE The Moose Beanie Buddy No Swing Tag
(2)
$9.95 New
$6.76 Used
Bubbles Retired 1998 Ty Beanie Buddy Yellow and Black 11in Tropical Fish 9323
Rank 52
Bubbles Retired 1998 Ty Beanie Buddy Yellow and Black 11in Tropical Fish 9323
(7)
$11.89 New
$4.99 Used
Ty 1999 Maple The Canada Bear Beanie Buddy -
Rank 53
Ty 1999 Maple The Canada Bear Beanie Buddy -
$12.89 New
$6.90 Used
Ty Beanie Buddy Purr Gray Leopard Spotted Kitty Cat 12" 2002 With Tags Buddies
Rank 54
Ty Beanie Buddy Purr Gray Leopard Spotted Kitty Cat 12" 2002 With Tags Buddies
(2)
$31.00 New
$29.97 Used
Ty Beanie Baby Buddies Beginning Bear Plush White Silver Stars Tag 13 In. 2000
Rank 55
Ty Beanie Baby Buddies Beginning Bear Plush White Silver Stars Tag 13 In. 2000
(2)
$8.00 New
No used products available
Vtg TY Beanie Buddies Righty Elephant 15” Plush Stuffed Animal Politics USA Flag
Rank 56
Vtg TY Beanie Buddies Righty Elephant 15” Plush Stuffed Animal Politics USA Flag
(1)
$11.99 New
$9.79 Used
Ty Beanie Buddy Sherbet The Sea Foam Green Lime Bear 9482 Plush Stuffed Toy
Rank 57
Ty Beanie Buddy Sherbet The Sea Foam Green Lime Bear 9482 Plush Stuffed Toy
(1)
$22.89 New
$15.89 Used
Ty Clubby II Blue Platinum Bear 14" Beanie Buddy 1999 Plush Boys Girls 3 MWMT
Rank 58
Ty Clubby II Blue Platinum Bear 14" Beanie Buddy 1999 Plush Boys Girls 3 MWMT
(4)
$10.99 New
$9.99 Used
Spinner 1999 Ty Beanie Buddy 9in Halloween Spider 3up Boys Girls 9334
Rank 59
Spinner 1999 Ty Beanie Buddy 9in Halloween Spider 3up Boys Girls 9334
(4)
$8.50 New
$6.50 Used
Ty 2001 Celebrate The Bear 15 Year Anniversary Beanie Buddy Tag
Rank 60
Ty 2001 Celebrate The Bear 15 Year Anniversary Beanie Buddy Tag
(2)
$16.99 New
$13.99 Used
Ty Beanie Buddy Husky Dog Named Nanook 3rd Generation MINT 1999
Rank 61
Ty Beanie Buddy Husky Dog Named Nanook 3rd Generation MINT 1999
(4)
$9.99 New
No used products available
Prince RARE Retired 2000 Ty Beanie Buddy 13in Bullfrog 3up Boys Girls 9401
Rank 62
Prince RARE Retired 2000 Ty Beanie Buddy 13in Bullfrog 3up Boys Girls 9401
$13.30 New
$3.00 Used
Ty Beanie Buddy Twigs Giraffe RARE 2nd Generation 1 Owner 1998
Rank 63
Ty Beanie Buddy Twigs Giraffe RARE 2nd Generation 1 Owner 1998
(3)
$18.89 New
$15.29 Used
TY Beanie Buddy The Cardinal 16” Plush Stuffed Animal Toy 2000
Rank 64
TY Beanie Buddy The Cardinal 16” Plush Stuffed Animal Toy 2000
$18.89 New
$17.00 Used
Cinders Retired 2001 Ty Beanie Buddy Sitting 9in Black Bear 3up Boys Girls 9443
Rank 65
Cinders Retired 2001 Ty Beanie Buddy Sitting 9in Black Bear 3up Boys Girls 9443
$12.00 New
$9.50 Used
Schnitzel RARE 2003 Ty Beanie Buddy Schnauzer 13in Dog 3 up Boys Girls 9493
Rank 66
Schnitzel RARE 2003 Ty Beanie Buddy Schnauzer 13in Dog 3 up Boys Girls 9493
(3)
$13.89 New
$9.99 Used
TY Beanie Buddy - GROOVY the Ty-Dyed Bear (14 inch) - MWMTs Stuffed Animal Toy
Rank 67
TY Beanie Buddy - GROOVY the Ty-Dyed Bear (14 inch) - MWMTs Stuffed Animal Toy
(2)
$10.00 New
No used products available
Ty Beanie Buddy Bear Named Clubby III 3rd Generation MINT 2000 Golden-blue
Rank 68
Ty Beanie Buddy Bear Named Clubby III 3rd Generation MINT 2000 Golden-blue
(2)
$13.30 New
$11.24 Used
Liberty White Head 2002 Patriotic 13in Ty Beanie Buddy Bear 3up Boys Girls 9488
Rank 69
Liberty White Head 2002 Patriotic 13in Ty Beanie Buddy Bear 3up Boys Girls 9488
(2)
$12.89 New
$10.99 Used
America Retired 2002 Ty Beanie Buddy Blue Plush Patriotic 12in Teddy Bear 9469
Rank 70
America Retired 2002 Ty Beanie Buddy Blue Plush Patriotic 12in Teddy Bear 9469
(5)
$8.05 New
No used products available
Ty 2001 Brigitte The Pink Poodle Dog Beanie Buddy
Rank 71
Ty 2001 Brigitte The Pink Poodle Dog Beanie Buddy
$27.99 New
$14.99 Used
Ty Beanie Buddy Chops The Lamb 2000 (14 Inches)
Rank 72
Ty Beanie Buddy Chops The Lamb 2000 (14 Inches)
(1)
$24.11 New
$15.99 Used
Hopper Retired 2001 Ty Beanie Buddy 14in Grey Easter Bunny Rabbit 3up 9438
Rank 73
Hopper Retired 2001 Ty Beanie Buddy 14in Grey Easter Bunny Rabbit 3up 9438
$17.99 New
No used products available
Inky Ty Beanie Buddy Original 2001 Nylon Pink Octopus
Rank 74
Inky Ty Beanie Buddy Original 2001 Nylon Pink Octopus
(1)
$16.89 New
$6.00 Used
Ty 2002 Classy The Bear Beanie Buddy 9458 Plush Stuffed Toy
Rank 75
Ty 2002 Classy The Bear Beanie Buddy 9458 Plush Stuffed Toy
(1)
$16.89 New
$10.99 Used
Ty Large Beanie Buddy Plush 2001 Loosy 14" Canadian Goose
Rank 76
Ty Large Beanie Buddy Plush 2001 Loosy 14" Canadian Goose
(1)
$16.89 New
$14.99 Used
TY LIPS the FISH BEANIE BUDDY - MINT with MINT TAGS
Rank 77
TY LIPS the FISH BEANIE BUDDY - MINT with MINT TAGS
(2)
$8.05 New
No used products available
Ty Beanie Buddy Eggbert Chick Hatching in Egg 3rd Gen Cute 2001
Rank 78
Ty Beanie Buddy Eggbert Chick Hatching in Egg 3rd Gen Cute 2001
$14.99 New
$10.99 Used
Stretch Retired 1998 Ty Beanie Buddy 16in Plush Ostrich 3up Boys Girls 9303
Rank 79
Stretch Retired 1998 Ty Beanie Buddy 16in Plush Ostrich 3up Boys Girls 9303
(4)
$8.99 New
$7.98 Used
Ty Beanie Buddy Buddies Lucky Ladybug 1999 Plush 9" Long About 11 Spots Soft
Rank 80
Ty Beanie Buddy Buddies Lucky Ladybug 1999 Plush 9" Long About 11 Spots Soft
(4)
$9.00 New
No used products available
Ty Beanie Buddy Pumkin the Jack-O-Lantern MWMT
Rank 81
Ty Beanie Buddy Pumkin the Jack-O-Lantern MWMT
$11.69 New
$9.59 Used
1997 Holiday Teddy 13in Ty Beanie Buddy Christmas Santa Hat Bear 3up 9053
Rank 82
1997 Holiday Teddy 13in Ty Beanie Buddy Christmas Santa Hat Bear 3up 9053
(4)
$8.05 New
$6.00 Used
Eucalyptus The Koala Bear Beanie Buddies Plush 10" Gray Cream VTG 1999 Ty Inc.
Rank 83
Eucalyptus The Koala Bear Beanie Buddies Plush 10" Gray Cream VTG 1999 Ty Inc.
$9.75 New
$5.00 Used
Ty Snowman Snowboy Plush Stuffed Animal 1999 Beanie Buddy Buddies Christmas
Rank 84
Ty Snowman Snowboy Plush Stuffed Animal 1999 Beanie Buddy Buddies Christmas
(7)
$6.49 New
No used products available
Ty Beanie Buddy Valentina The Bear 14in With Tag
Rank 85
Ty Beanie Buddy Valentina The Bear 14in With Tag
(1)
$13.89 New
No used products available
Kirby White West Highland Scottish Terrier Plush Dog 2001 Ty Beanie Buddy 12in.
Rank 86
Kirby White West Highland Scottish Terrier Plush Dog 2001 Ty Beanie Buddy 12in.
$14.95 New
No used products available
Ty Beanie Buddy - Blessed The Angel Bear (10.5 Inch) Stuffed Animal Toy A179
Rank 87
Ty Beanie Buddy - Blessed The Angel Bear (10.5 Inch) Stuffed Animal Toy A179
(2)
$9.97 New
No used products available
Ty Addison Blue Baseball Bear Cubs 13" Beanie Buddy Plush 2002 Boys Girls 3 NT
Rank 88
Ty Addison Blue Baseball Bear Cubs 13" Beanie Buddy Plush 2002 Boys Girls 3 NT
$8.00 New
No used products available
Ty Large Plush Beanie Buddy Singabear ( Bear Asia Pacific ) MWMT
Rank 89
Ty Large Plush Beanie Buddy Singabear ( Bear Asia Pacific ) MWMT
(1)
$28.89 New
No used products available
14" 2002 Ty Beanie Buddy Vanda The Bear Plush Stuffed Toy With Original Tags
Rank 90
14" 2002 Ty Beanie Buddy Vanda The Bear Plush Stuffed Toy With Original Tags
$13.34 New
No used products available
Retired Ty Beanie Buddy Admiral Penguin 2006 # 90053
Rank 91
Retired Ty Beanie Buddy Admiral Penguin 2006 # 90053
(4)
$20.00 New
$19.99 Used
Ty Empress Cat Kitten Beanie Buddy Plush 2003 Yellow Orange TySilk Buddies E3
Rank 92
Ty Empress Cat Kitten Beanie Buddy Plush 2003 Yellow Orange TySilk Buddies E3
(3)
$38.89 New
$34.99 Used
Ty Beanie Buddies Plush Leonardo TMNT Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtle 9 in
Rank 93
Ty Beanie Buddies Plush Leonardo TMNT Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtle 9 in
(1)
$14.49 New
$10.99 Used
2002 Ty 10 in Beanie Buddy Giganto The Mammoth Stuffed Animal Toy With Tags
Rank 94
2002 Ty 10 in Beanie Buddy Giganto The Mammoth Stuffed Animal Toy With Tags
(2)
$23.99 New
$6.00 Used
2003 Ty Beanie Buddy Filly The Horse MWMT
Rank 95
2003 Ty Beanie Buddy Filly The Horse MWMT
$23.99 New
No used products available
Ty Beanie Buddy - Aberdeen The Black West Highland Terrier 25cm
Rank 96
Ty Beanie Buddy - Aberdeen The Black West Highland Terrier 25cm
No new products available
No used products available
2001 Ty Beanie Buddy Wrinkles The Bull Dog Stuffed Animal Very Cute Boys/girls
Rank 97
2001 Ty Beanie Buddy Wrinkles The Bull Dog Stuffed Animal Very Cute Boys/girls
(3)
No new products available
No used products available